Our Bakery Collection

This is our growing “bake library”—a collection of items we’ve made over time and may offer again. It will evolve as we test new recipes and add fresh favorites.

Our Bakery Sourdough Classes Policy & Disclaimer

Tip: When porch pickup dates are announced, the order link + the “what’s baking” list will be posted on the blog/social. This page stays evergreen as your catalog.

Sourdough & Savory

This is where it all began. Our sourdough and savory bakes are rooted in simple ingredients, long fermentation, and a love for everyday bread that fits real life. These are the loaves and savory favorites we return to often — steady, nourishing, and made to be shared at the table.

• Golden Semolina Sourdough ($12)
• Sourdough English Muffins ($6) — 4 count
• Soft Sourdough Pretzel Bites ($12) — bag of 20

Cookies

These cookies are baked with joy and generosity in mind — the kind you bring to a gathering, tuck into a lunchbox, or enjoy with a cup of coffee in a quiet moment. Some are classic, some a little indulgent, and all are recipes we’ve loved enough to bake again and again.

• Chocolate Chip Cookies ($18) — 1 dozen
• Peanut Butter Cookies ($18) — 1 dozen
• Chocolate Bliss Cookies ($12) — 1 dozen
• Almond Oatmeal Cookies ($18) — 1 dozen
• Kitchen Sink Cookie ($22) — 1 dozen

Muffins & Scones

Soft, tender, and meant for slow mornings or afternoon treats, our muffins and scones lean cozy and seasonal. You’ll find familiar flavors alongside a few unexpected pairings — always thoughtful, never fussy, and perfect for sharing (or not).

• Strawberry White Chocolate Muffins ($18) — 1 dozen
• Pumpkin Cream Cheese Swirl Muffins ($14) — 1 dozen
• Blackberry Lavender White Chocolate Scones ($14) — 6 scones

Cupcakes & Cakes

These bakes are for celebrating — birthdays, milestones, or “just because” moments that deserve something special. From simple classics to layered favorites, these are cakes and cupcakes we’ve made for family, friends, and customers alike, and may offer again as seasons and schedules allow.

• Chocolate Cupcakes ($22) — 1 dozen
• Tropical Sunshine Cupcakes ($32 per dozen or two-layer 9" round)
• Brown Butter Pecan Cupcakes (6 for $18 / 1 dozen for $36)
• Classic Carrot Cake ($25 single layer / $50 three layer)

Ordering note: This page is an archive of offerings. When we open porch pickup dates, you’ll see the current menu + ordering details posted on the blog and social. This collection will continue to grow as we test new recipes and revisit old favorites. Availability varies by season and schedule.

Questions or private classes? Email: susan@keepitsimplesusan.com